Pricing is the fastest lever on profit. A 5% price increase that keeps most of your customers often adds more profit than a 20% rise in sales. Yet many small shops pick prices by copying a competitor or adding a round markup to cost.

Here's a better method.

Step 1: Know your true cost per order

Most pricing mistakes come from underestimating costs. Include everything:

CostExample per unit
Product cost (including inbound shipping)£12.00
Packaging£0.80
Outbound shipping (your share)£3.50
Payment fees£1.10
Platform or marketplace fees£2.00
Returns and refunds (average share)£1.20
Marketing cost per sale£7.00
Total cost per unit£27.60

If you sell internationally, add duties and taxes. See landed cost explained.

Step 2: Set your margin floor

Decide the minimum profit per unit you need to cover overheads (rent, staff, software, your salary) and make a profit.

Price floor = total cost per unit + minimum profit per unit

If you need £8 per unit: £27.60 + £8 = £35.60. Anything below that loses money on overheads. Our break-even analysis guide and profit margin calculator help.

Remember: margin and markup are different.

  • Markup = profit ÷ cost. £10 profit on a £20 cost = 50% markup.
  • Margin = profit ÷ price. £10 profit on a £30 price = 33% margin.

Read gross margin vs net margin.

Step 3: Check the market

Look at what customers compare you with:

  • Direct competitors selling the same or similar products.
  • Marketplaces (Amazon, eBay, Etsy).
  • AI shopping assistants, which now compare prices in seconds. See agentic commerce.

Note not just price but delivery speed, returns, reviews and bundle offers. A £2 higher price with next-day delivery and free returns often wins.

Step 4: Choose a pricing position

PositionWhen it works
Below marketYou have a genuine cost advantage, or want to win share fast (risky)
At marketCommodity products; compete on service and delivery
Above marketStrong brand, better quality, unique product, great reviews

Most small shops do best at or slightly above market, with a clear reason to choose them.

Step 5: Use pricing psychology carefully

  • Charm pricing (£19.99): can lift sales for value-focused products.
  • Round pricing (£20): can feel more premium and simple.
  • Anchoring: show a premium option first so the mid option looks reasonable.
  • Bundles: "3 for £45" raises order value.
  • Free shipping thresholds: set just above your average order value.
  • Decoy pricing: a middle option that makes your preferred option look best.

Stay honest. "Was" prices must reflect prices you genuinely charged; in the UK and EU, misleading reference prices can breach consumer law.

Step 6: Test prices instead of guessing

Ways to test without upsetting customers:

  1. Sequential testing: change the price for two to four weeks, then compare conversion rate and profit (not just sales) with the previous period. Watch for seasonality.
  2. New product testing: launch new products at a higher price; it's easier to lower than raise.
  3. Bundle and offer testing: test bundles, thresholds and gifts rather than base price.
  4. Ad landing page testing: test price presentation on landing pages for paid traffic.

The goal is maximum profit, not maximum sales:

PriceUnits soldProfit per unitTotal profit
£34500£6.40£3,200
£38430£10.40£4,472
£42330£14.40£4,752
£46210£18.40£3,864

In this example, £42 earns the most profit despite fewer sales.

Let your data find the price

Zelvorm Price Lab finds the price that makes you the most money from your own sales history, your costs and competitors' prices. It's free.

When to raise prices

  • Costs have risen and margins have shrunk.
  • You sell out quickly or have a waiting list.
  • Your reviews and reputation have improved.
  • Competitors have raised prices.

Raise prices with confidence: explain improvements where relevant, honour existing quotes and grandfather subscriptions if appropriate.

The short version

Price from true cost per order (including fees, returns and marketing), set a margin floor, check what customers compare you with, choose a position, use pricing psychology honestly and test prices to find the one that maximises total profit, not sales.

Need help with pricing strategy for your shop? Our e-commerce team and consulting team can help.